Office of Adjudication  > Alternative Dispute Resolution > Alternative Dispute Resolution Pamphlet

Alternative Dispute Resolution Pamphlet

What is Alternative Dispute Resolution?

In alternative dispute resolution (ADR), the injured worker and employer representatives talk informally with the help of a workers' compensation judge. The judge helps the parties to settle the case by talking through their differences. ADR may take the form of mediation, a settlement conference or an informal conference.

How can ADR help me?

ADR can provide several advantages over litigating a case to decision. These include:
  • Saving time, money, and aggravation. If used at the right time, ADR can save one or both parties some of the costs and stress that come from trying a case to decision.
     
  • Informality. ADR involves “off-the-record” conversations instead of sworn, recorded testimony and exhibits.
     
  • Improved communications. Both sides have the chance to talk about their needs and interests. This can help the parties better understand one another, and find common ground for building an agreement.
     
  • Results that are more predictable and better centered on your needs because you have some control. A judge’s decision is limited by the evidence presented and the law. A negotiated settlement can be tailored to suit what the parties need, rather than what one party can prove.
     
  • Finality without repeated petition filings or appeals. If the judge approves a settlement agreement, the areas of disagreement are reduced or eliminated. This makes it less likely that appeals or more petitions will be filed.

Do I have to use ADR?

The decision whether to settle your case is always yours. However, if either you or your employer files a petition with the Bureau, the law requires the workers' compensation judge to schedule mediation. This mediation is mandatory unless the judge concludes that it would be futile. 

May I use ADR if I don't settle after mandatory mediation?

If the case does not settle at mandatory mediation, the parties may participate in voluntary ADR later in the proceedings. The parties may also request voluntary ADR later in the proceedings if the judge had previously found it futile.

Do I have to have an attorney?

The law does not require you to have an attorney in ADR. You may find, though, that having an attorney makes ADR easier and gives you a better end result.
 
Note regarding informal conferences under Section 402.1 of the Workers’ Compensation Act: Each party may be represented, but the employer may only be represented by an attorney at an informal conference if the employee is also represented by an attorney.

Who would conduct the ADR session?

The judge assigned to hear your case will schedule a mandatory mediation with a judge designated by the Office of Adjudication.
 
The following workers’ compensation judges are available for voluntary ADR sessions where petitions are pending:
 
Central District
Eastern District
Southeastern District
Western District
Harrisburg Office
Paul Baker
Wayne Dietrich
Brian Eader
Karl Peckmann
Patrick Sheldon
 
Pottsville Office
Wayne Fegley
Thomas Kutz
Wayne Rapkin
 
Scranton Office
Patrick Cummings
Joseph Grady
 
Wilkes-Barre Office
Brian Hemak
Joseph Sebastianelli
 
Williamsport Office
Karl Baldys
Kenneth Walsh
Allentown Office
Bruce Doman
Audrey Beach
Beverly Doneker
 
Bristol Office
Robert Benischeck
Michael Rosen
 
Lancaster Office
Robert Goduto
Michael Hetrick
Robert O'Donnell
 
Malvern Office
Joseph Hakun
Kelly Melcher
Donald Poorman
 
Reading Office
Terry Knox
Brian Puhala
James Stapleton
Philadelphia, Arch Street
Patricia Bachman
Lawrence Beck
Debra Bowers
Sandra Craig
Joseph Hagan
Stephen Harlen
Marc Harrison
Denise Krass
Francine Lincicome
Andrea McCormick
Pamela Santoro
David Slom
 
Upper Darby
Kathleen DiLorenzo
Joseph Stokes
Altoona Office
Robert Vonada
 
Brookville Office
Geoffrey Seacrist
 
Clearfield Office
Michael Koll
 
Erie Office
Carmen Lugo
Jean Wright
 
Greensburg Office
Irving Bloom
Paul Costelnock
Ada Guyton
 
Johnstown Office
David Cicola
Charles Getty
Steven Minnich
 
New Castle Office
Alfred Benedict
Robert Steiner
 
Pittsburgh Office
Pamela Briston
Susan Cercone
David Henry
Cheryl Ignasiak
Rosalia Parker
David Torrey
Kathleen Vallely
 
Uniontown Office
Anne Coholan
William Lowman
 
Washington Office
Eric Jones
Charles Lawton
 
Note: An individual judge’s availability may be limited by his or her schedule or workload.

What does it cost to use ADR?

There is no cost for ADR services if provided by a workers’ compensation judge.

How do I set up a voluntary ADR session on my case?

Informal conferences may be scheduled by filing the Notice of Request for an Informal Conference form (LIBC-753) with the judge hearing the pending petitions. This form is also available from any judge’s office. Both parties must sign the form. The district judge manager will assign the case to a judge other than the judge hearing the pending petitions.
 
To request a voluntary mediation or settlement conference, the parties should first agree on a specific judge. Once they agree, they should contact that judge’s office directly to determine his or her availability. If the parties cannot agree on a judge to conduct the mediation or settlement conference, they should contact the district judge manager. Click here to find the judge managers' contact information.
 
If you would like more information or have any other questions, contact the attorney representing you in your workers’ compensation case. If you do not have an attorney, contact the office of the judge assigned to hear your case.
Contact UsCommonwealth PortalContact the Web Team | Privacy PolicyDisclaimer
Copyright ©  Commonwealth of Pennsylvania